IRB Reliance
Multi-Site Research
Multi-site research refers to human subject research conducted at external sites, which are considered to be locations external to Michigan State University (MSU) (e.g., not on MSU campus, not within an MSU facility, location not under the jurisdiction or control of MSU). There are different requirements based on whether the external site, or its employees, are engaged in the human subject research conducted by an MSU investigator.
Engagement
The HRPP determines whether an external site is engaged in the research using the U.S. Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP) guidance, “Guidance on Engagement of Institutions in Human Subjects Research.” However, external sites may also require IRB review based on their institutional requirements. It is important to check with each external site to determine if the site requires IRB approval based on the specific human research project. For more information, please see HRPP Manual 4-12, Engagement.
IRB Reliance
For multi-site research with engaged external sites, arrangements may be made for institutions to rely on one another for IRB review. MSU may enter into a reliance agreement to rely on another institution’s IRB review or to allow another institution to rely on MSU’s IRB review. Such agreements are made to help reduce duplicate IRB review when appropriate or required.
NIH Single IRB Requirements
The Final NIH Policy on Use of a Single IRB for Multi-Site Research establishes the expectation that all domestic sites participating in multi-site studies involving non-exempt human subjects research funded by NIH will use a single Institutional Review Board (sIRB).
We highly recommend that you contact the HRPP early and as soon as possible, as the decision of which IRB should serve as the single IRB may require discussions between the institution’s IRBs.
For more information, visit the Single IRB webpage.
Revised Common Rule Single IRB Requirements
Projects seeking funding from a Federal department or agency that has adopted the Revised Common Rule for the protection of human subjects in research are required to identify and use a Single Institutional Review Board (Single IRB) when certain criteria are met. Any institution located in the United States that is engaged in cooperative non-exempt research must rely upon approval by a Single IRB for that portion of the research that is conducted in the United States, with limited exceptions.
At MSU, this requirement only applies to projects funded or supported by a Federal department or agency that has adopted the Revised Common Rule for the protection of human subjects.
We highly recommend that you contact the HRPP early and as soon as possible, as the decision of which IRB should serve as the single IRB may require discussions between the institution’s IRBs.
For more information, visit the Single IRB webpage.
SMART IRB
MSU is a Participating Institution in SMART IRB! The SMART IRB is funded by NIH and is a platform designed to harmonize and streamline the IRB review process for multisite studies. The SMART IRB agreement enables reliance on a study-by-study basis with clearly defined roles and responsibilities and eliminates the need to review project specific IRB Authorization Agreements. MSU requires use of the SMART IRB agreement when the other institution is a SMART IRB participating institution, with limited exceptions. When the SMART IRB agreement is used, a Letter of Acknowledgement (LOA) must be in place between the institutions, or the reliance must be documented via the SMART IRB online reliance system. Learn more about SmartIRB.org
Types of Agreements for Reliance
Process
Each reliance agreement is situation and context-dependent and the process may vary, depending upon the type of reliance agreement. The IRB Reliance Office coordinates the reliance process and the MSU Institutional Official retains final authority to determine whether MSU may enter into a reliance agreement.
If you are conducting research at multiple institutions or entities or will engage collaborators at multiple institutions, please contact the IRB Reliance Office to determine the possibility of reliance or if reliance is required.